9 Organic Mattress Toppers Reviewed & Ranked (Wool, Crib, Memory Foam & More)

By Samson Opanda | Updated on September 20, 2021

Organic mattress toppers are made from naturally occurring and environmentally friendly materials. Latex, wool, and cotton are some of the most common materials used in the toppers.

But, in each of these categories, some products seem to go above and beyond.

To find out more about how these mattress toppers ranked against one another, keep reading…

An 8 Billion Trees graphic of what to look for when switching to an organic mattress cover.

Among latex-based mattress top covers, Avocado, Latex-for-Less, and Sleep-for-less are some of the best toppers. The toppers are made from eco-friendly materials, are certified as organic, and provide social benefits including hiring craftsmen for handmade products.

Birch, Plush Beds and Coyuchi Mattress are the best performing brands among wool-based mattress top covers. The products come from natural sheep wool, are certified, and take eco-friendliness seriously.

Memory Foam, Coop Home Goods, and Rawganique emerged as the top three in cotton-based mattress toppers. The cotton fiber used in these products ensures they are breathable and soft. These toppers are also eco-friendly and are highly absorbent to keep the mattress surface dry.

A Ranking System for Eco-Conscious Brands

While most ranking systems do a great job highlighting the best performing organic mattress toppers, unfortunately some do not have proper selection criteria for choosing the winners.

This ranking addresses this weakness by having defined criteria for making it to the top three:
First, the mattress topper must be made from organic materials such as latex, wool, and cotton to make it to the list. Toppers made from purely synthetic materials or a combination of synthetic and natural materials are disqualified for not being purely organic.

Secondly, only toppers certified with international environmental certifications made it to the list. The certifications imply that other third parties acknowledge the suitability of the topper, making the product offered reliable.

The final ranking factor involves overall sustainability, social accountability, and regard for the Earth and its resources. For this reason, brands that carbon offset or stress social change are ranked higher, as these brands make more of a direct positive impact on the world.

This ranking system has grouped organic mattress toppers into three categories based on the material used in production, and the three best products in each category are presented. Grouping the products based on raw materials ensures there is no unfair comparison between products with distinct characteristics. It also accounts for material uniqueness, which is important when choosing your most preferred topper.

Natural Latex Mattress Top Covers

As the name suggests, these types of mattress covers are made from latex, which provides an extra layer of foam that you can add on top of your mattress for improved firmness. Latex top covers adopt a wide range of technologically advanced production methods.

However, the most common one entails pouring latex into a mold that stabilizes to form the final product. It should be noted, however, that more than 3 million people in the US have latex allergies, so be careful choosing this material, depending on who may be using this bed.7

Advantages of Latex Mattress Toppers

The extra layer of latex provided by these types of toppers ensures your mattress stays usable for longer. The toppers allow for a sound sleep on the top of a soft latex material for maximum comfort, as they come in different sizes and degrees of firmness.

More importantly, these top covers are made from natural materials, making them organic. They, therefore, have minimal damage to the natural environment as they release less carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions.

Ranking of 3 Best Natural Latex Top Covers

  • Avocado

This product is made purely from natural latex. The latex used for the product comes from Indian farms, which operate within the USDA National Organic Program framework.4 So committed is the company in ensuring it uses only latex, that it has come up with a certification mechanism for all latex used by the firm.

Termed GOLS organic certified latex, all raw material used in production meets the criteria outlined in the certification for best results. Externally, the Avocado products are certified with the Vegan Action, PETA, and other international climate change and organics certifications.

Avocado mattress top covers have taken certification a step further in all their products. Even the sewing threads for the top covers are certified by OEKO-TEX Standard 100 for environmental compliance.4

  • Latex for Less

Like the previous one, this mattress topper is made from pure latex. The company boasts of selecting the latex themselves through single-origin supply. The use of a single-origin supply is designed to ensure that all the latex going into the company’s products comes from known and single sources.3

By doing so, the company can track the quality of the latex all the way up to the farm level. To further promote eco-friendliness by minimizing emissions, Latex-for-Less products do not go through conventional manufacturing processes, which involve multiple suppliers and outsourced factory work.

Instead, these products are handcrafted in the US. The commitment of Latex-for-Less in promoting environmentally friendly products has landed them two international certifications. The OEKE-TEK Certified Latex affirms that all the latex used by the company is internationally certified, while the GOTS Certification confirms that the company uses organic products.3

An image of the Sleep On Latex Green Natural Latex Mattress Topper

  • Sleep on Latex6

Sleep-on-Latex mattress toppers are made from natural latex grown in Sri Lanka. The company takes precautions to ensure that only organically grown latex produced in Sri Lanka is used in its products.5

By doing so, the company promotes eco-friendliness by using natural organic products and promotes social responsibility by supporting organic farming in a third-world country. To further demonstrate commitment to environmental courses, the company has adopted two international certifications.

The GOLS Organic Certification Standard for the Natural Latex Foam confirms organic raw material usage. Additional standards adopted by the company include the Global Organic Latex Standard, OEKE – TEX Standard 100, and Green Guard Gold Standard.5

Wool Mattress Toppers: Ranking the 3 Best Wool Mattress Toppers

Wool mattress top covers are made from animal wool. Farmers shear sheep in their farms and supply the wool to mattress companies, which they use to make the toppers. The main selling point of these toppers is that they are made from naturally occurring wool in animals, making them less adverse to the environment than other toppers. Sheep also need their wool cut in order to live a happy, healthy life, so wool is an animal-friendly choice as well.6

Advantages of Wool Mattress Toppers

As noted earlier, wool toppers support environmental and social conservation by investing in natural animal products as their primary raw material. Other advantages of these toppers include its hypoallergenic property, which ensures it does not trigger adverse allergic reactions for some people. The fabric is breathable and sumptuous, allowing for a comfortable and well-rested sleep.

  • Birch

This company manufactures mattress top covers made from all-natural, organic, and environmentally friendly products. While the company has a range of natural toppers for
customers to choose from, their wool toppers are the most popular.

To ensure that all the company’s products adhere to eco-friendliness and social responsibility principles, Birch scrutinizes its supply chain to confirm that all producers have complied with the relevant laws, including creating fair working conditions.4

The company also donates 1 percent of revenue proceeds to The National Forest Foundation and an additional 1 percent to the Planet as part of its corporate and social responsibility.4 Thanks to this and other similar initiatives, the company is RainForest Alliance Certified. Additional certifications for the company’s products include the PGC Wool Integrity Program and the OEKE – TEX.

  • Plush Beds

This company makes both wool and latex mattress top covers. The former is, however, more popular than the latter hence our listing the product here. The wool mattress toppers of the company are made from wool sheep, making the product natural, organic, and eco-friendly.

All the wool from the company comes from approved farmers who have been mandated to ensure all shearing activities are chemical-free and avoid animal cruelty.4 By so doing, the wool products of the company are free from scouring agents, smells, and other chemicals that may trigger allergic reactions to some users.

As part of its commitment to social responsibility, the company handcrafts all its products in the US, making them unique with a human touch that many users prefer.4

  • Coyuchi Mattress Topper

This company makes wool-based mattress toppers in the US. The firm sources the wool from a ranch in California as part of its quality control process to ensure it gets the best raw materials.4
The method of manufacturing the topper is also designed to promote quality, addressing environmental and social concerns. Upon arriving at the factory floor, the wool is washed using biodegradable soap and rinsed with water from Lake Huron.

After this, the wool is air-dried and processed using steam instead of chemicals to ensure the final product remains natural. To stay updated with standard best practices of eco-friendliness, the company has partnered with various organizations committed to the course, including the American Apparel & Footwear Association.4 All products from the company have the MADE SAFE seal, which implies they are made from non-harmful substances with no adverse effects on animal and plant health.

Cotton Mattress Top Covers: Ranking of 3 Best Cotton Mattress Toppers

Cotton mattress covers are made from pure cotton, mostly sourced from large farms that are certified as organic producers. After harvesting, the cotton is processed into a fiber fabric used to make the toppers.

Advantages Of Cotton Mattress Top Covers

The major selling point for cotton-based mattress top covers is their plushness and durability. Most people view natural cotton as a luxurious product that delivers additional environmental benefits.

The toppers are also long-lasting compared to those made from other synthetic materials. Additional benefits include a high absorbent capacity that sucks sweat, keeping your skin surface dry as you sleep, and bulk density that ensures the cotton fabric remains breathable.

  • Memory Foam Mattress Toppers

Brentwood Homes is the producer of this mattress top cover. The toppers are made of bio-
foam, a biodegradable material that delivers the same insulation properties as other synthetic products, as well as soft cotton.

The material is also soft and breathable, allowing for a comfortable sleep. It has also been certified under the CertiPUR certified foams.2 The certification confirms that the products are made without o-zone destroyers, mercury, flame retardants, lead, formaldehyde, and other harmful substances.

Additional certifications by the company include Climate Neutral Certifications, which implies net-zero emissions in all operations, and the Green Guard Certification that ensures all manufacturers use environmentally friendly raw materials.2

  • Coop Home Goods

Coop Home Goods Mattress toppers are made from cotton. Beyond the eco-benefits of using cotton, a natural product, the toppers are waterproof and have breathable sides for extra protection and comfort.1

The company also allows users to return the product if they are unsatisfied after using it for 100 nights. On certification, the product is certified by the OEKO – TEX certification standard, implying it is not made from harmful pollutants such as PVC.1

 

An image of the Rawnique Louisiana natural cotton mattress topper.

  • Rawganique7

Founded 20 years ago, Rawganique is a mattress company committed to environmental friendliness.4All its products, including its cotton mattress toppers, are handmade to minimize adverse environmental and social impacts.

The products are also marked with a Vegan Stamp to infer that they are made without any form of animal cruelty or slave labor. The company’s cotton toppers are made from organic cotton certified under the USDA – Certified organic cotton protocol. To enhance consumer satisfaction, Rawganique offers custom-made toppers at client requests.4

Choosing the Right Organic Mattress Topper For Your Eco-Friendly Lifestyle

A good ranking system should have a proper selection criterion for the best-performing products, which is what the goal was with this review of the top organic mattress toppers. These rankings are made to promote the use of organic materials to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and mitigate the adverse effects of climate change.

With most of the world currently feeling the effects of the climate crisis, the necessity of companies to engage in business practices with less adverse impacts on the environment has become all the more apparent.

With this list, buyers keen on eco-friendly products can stay informed and make rewarding choices. Even with such a small decision, you can make a big impact by selecting a mattress topper that improves the environment and makes the Earth better.


References

1Amazon. 2021. Coop Home Goods Mattress Protector Cover – Waterproof, Ultra Soft Breathable Bed Mattress Topper – Silent Mattress Pad Encasement – Oeko-TEX Certified Lulltra Fabric – King. Accessed August 30, 2021. https://www.amazon.com/Waterproof-Protector-Coop-Home-Goods/dp/B00UKHSNYI.

2Brentwood. 2021. Brentwood Home. Accessed August 30, 2021. https://www.brentwoodhome.com/products/memory-foam-mattress-toppers. Latex-for-Less. 2021. The Latex-for-Less Topper. Accessed August 30, 2021. https://www.latexforless.com/products/latex-topper.

3LeafScore. 2021. The 11 Best Organic & Non-Toxic Mattress Toppers. Accessed August 30, 2021. https://www.leafscore.com/eco-friendly-bed-products/best-organic-non-toxic-mattress-toppers/. Sleep-on-Latex. 2021. Pure Green Natural Latex Mattress Topper. Accessed August 30, 2021. https://sleeponlatex.com/products/natural-latex-mattress-topper.

4There is no such thing as humane wool when it is left on the sheep: Why sheep shearing is absolutely necessary for sheep welfare. (n.d.). Retrieved August 30, 2021, from https://www.asas.org/taking-stock/taking-stock/2014/07/14/there-is-no-such-thing-as-humane-wool-when-it-is-left-on-the-sheep-why-sheep-shearing-is-absolutely-necessary-for-sheep-welfare

5Latex allergy – Symptoms and causes. (2020, October 16). Retrieved August 30, 2021, from https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/latex-allergy/symptoms-causes/syc-20374287

6Image source: Sleep On Latex, https://sleeponlatex.com/products/natural-latex-mattress-topper

7Image Source: Rawnique, https://rawganique.com/products/organic-cotton-topper-handmade-in-usa-louisiana